Hello dear
Welcome to Mikey's Pizza
Welcome to Mikey's Pizza, a hidden gem located in the charming town of Crested Butte, Colorado. Known for its delectable thin-crust slices and generous calzones, this eatery merges culinary quality with affordability. Customers rave about the flavorful Mikey's Marinara and the fresh ingredients that elevate each dish. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or indulging in a whole pizza, the friendly staff ensures a satisfying experience. With unique outdoor seating fashioned from skis, the laid-back atmosphere enhances your dining pleasure. Mikey's Pizza is a must-visit for pizza aficionados seeking both taste and value in a cozy setting.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Garlic Bread
Shell Pasta W/ Marinara
The Margheritta
The Greek
About
Mikey's Pizza
Welcome to Mikey's Pizza, an unassuming gem nestled in the heart of Crested Butte, Colorado. Located at 611 3rd St, this charming eatery may seem like a simple hole-in-the-wall, but its culinary offerings are anything but ordinary. Renowned for its outstanding thin-crust pizza, Mikey's has quickly earned a reputation among locals and visitors alike for serving up some of the best pizza in town at surprisingly affordable prices.
The allure of Mikey's lies in its distinctive New York-style crust—thin, crispy, and perfectly balanced—with a variety of toppings that can be customized to your liking. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty veggie pizza or something with more zing like their specialty pies topped with pickles and even cream cheese as per a delighted customer’s request, Mikey’s promises to deliver a pizza experience tailored to your palate.
Beyond pizza, Mikey's also offers a selection of fresh salads, including the vibrant Greek Salad and the hearty Chef Salad, perfect for those seeking a lighter fare. The quality of ingredients shines through in every dish, further enhancing the simple yet flavorful offerings at this delightful eatery. And if you're in the mood for a sweet treat, don’t miss out on their delectable Chocolate Chip Cookies and White Chocolate Mac Cookies, each available for just $2.50.
The atmosphere at Mikey's is laid-back and welcoming. With outdoor seating fashioned from skis, you can enjoy your meal while soaking up the rustic charm of Crested Butte. Although the indoor seating is limited, the friendly staff ensures that your dining experience is pleasant and memorable. As one satisfied patron noted, "Fantastic pizza at a reasonable price and friendly staff" captures the essence of Mikey's commitment to quality and customer service.
Whether you’re shopping for a quick slice or hosting a pizza night with friends, Mikey's Pizza stands out as a community favorite. A visit is indeed one of the best investments you can make in your culinary adventures. So, grab your appetite and head over to Mikey's Pizza—a slice of New York flavor in the heart of Colorado awaits!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ best 4 you can ever spend on a huge thin crust slice! despite the rest of this town having seemingly steep food prices, these guys are cooking up some amazing pizza for a low price. super friendly hole in the wall! definitely recommend! ”
“ This place is great! You can stop by and just buy a single slice or you can buy a whole pizza! The pizza is really good and the single slices are pretty big and filling. It has really cute outside seating the seats are made out of skis which fits the vibe and its a very chill atmosphere. Its also great if you just want to take a pizza home. However if you are looking to sit inside, this is not your place. Also the pizza is really good and the single slices are pretty big. The man that was working there I assume he owns it, he was very nice also. ”
“ The most NY of crusts around. They are willing to customize their pizzas. Brought the team pickles, vinegar chips, and cream cheese and they put together a masterpiece of a pizza! ”
“ Fantastic pizza at a reasonable price and friendly staff. We got a large veggie and were not disappointed. Excellent crust, tasty sauce and ingredients seemed fresh and high quality. ”
“ The calzones are very generously sized. The red sauce had a lot of flavor and complexity for a walkup joint. Easy order, easy delivery. The salad dressing was Ken's (not homemade) but did the job, and the greens were fresh. ”
“ Great pizza. Super nice guy. By the slice is probably the best deal in CB. ”
“ We absolutely loved Mikey’s Pizza; we ended going twice. The best pizza in Crested Butte. The first night there, my husband forgot his drink so we drove all the way back 3 min before closing and they were kind enough to open the door right before they locked up. The ingredients are perfect and the sauce is amazing. Definitely a thumbs up, check it out if you’re ever in Crested Butte. ”
“ Had a solid pepperoni New York slice! I'm miles away now, but can't wait to go back! ”